Summary Study Paper

In the article Hare does address the issue of person hood. The pro-life advocates tend to argue that abortion does violate the fundamental right of a person. On the other hand, Hare claims that the notion of person is ambiguous because many legal and moral rights that appear inalienable for a person are not recognized in the country until a person reaches the age of 18. Hare tries to address this question of person hood as he believes that we should not call the fetus a person and consider it as the main argument against abortion. The person hood of the fetus can only be established after the fetus right to life is established. The argument that Hare provides regarding personhood does make sense as when arguing about the right of the fetus as a person; there are some rights that an individual is never allowed to practice until they are 18.
In the argument, Hare does use Kantian argument through reminding that the moral rules and duties should be applied universally meaning to all people and at all times. Therefore, the claim that abortion should not be practiced should be universal in that it applies to both the present and the future pregnant women. When considering Kant argument, Hare does come to the conclusion that all the interested stakeholders in the pregnancy should observe the importance of the wishes of the fetus and those of the mother. In this case, because the fetus cannot be able to express its wishes, then the state should get involved to assure its status and rights.
Jarvis Thomson’s argument regarding person hood is that she grants that a fetus is a person. Although she grants the personhood of the fetus, she believes that the claim of the right to life superseding the right to decide regarding a person’s body is not true. Thomson does not consider the claim of the right as a person as an argument against abortion as sound. The argument that Thomson presents in the article is outstanding as it helps to indicate why we cannot morally claim that the right to life does surpass the right of a person deciding what they want for their body.
In the argument, Thomson does use the scenario of the violinist in discussing a person’s right to life. Thomson continues testing the pro-life argument on the right to life-based on different contexts. From the scenarios she presents, she claims that the pro-life position cannot be acceptable by the accepted standards of justice or morality. In her arguments, she claims that every person has the right to life as the fetus has a right to life and also the mother has the right to deciding what happens in her body.

Sherry Roberts is the author of this paper. A senior editor at Melda Research in help writing nursing research paper if you need a similar paper you can place your order for customized papers.



Tags:

Sherry
Great Articles
Logo
Shopping cart