I almost lost my life to the 2013 game Cookie Clicker. My final film project had been canceled for political reasons right as I was graduating from film school, and the fallout from that had led to my breakup. In a state of exhaustion and rage, I fell victim to the first viral idle game, Cookie Clicker, the most malicious game I’ve ever played.
The sneakiness of Cookie Clicker lies in the fact that it begins as a tiny, unimportant nuisance but quickly expands until it needs your full focus. Idle games appear to be a harmless pastime. It’s just something that loops and plays itself in the background. You are welcome to check in on it whenever you like, but doing so is entirely optional. You are always playing it, even when you think you aren’t. To be idle is to be inactive, immobile, and meaningless. In reality, though, that has nothing at all in common with the experience of playing a purely passive game.
One way of putting it is that you never stop playing, which is what “you’re always playing” means. If you let a game like Cookie Clicker run in the background, you won’t be as productive as you could be if you were constantly checking on it, making decisions, and increasing cookie production at the first possible second. In a game like Cookie Clicker, where the only objective is to increase the number, losing focus for even a second means you’re not running your Cookie empire at full speed. I had to get away from Cookie Clicker when I realized it was consuming my life, but the game’s influence has lingered.
Since then, I’ve largely been successful in avoiding mindless entertainment. Infrequently, I’ll play a game like Leaf Blower Revolution or Melvor Idle, but I always know when to stop before I get too immersed. Finally released on Steam late last year, Cookie Clicker has received tens of thousands of five-star ratings and has been hailed as a critical and commercial success. Even though I haven’t and won’t partake, it’s obvious that these games continue to resonate with players even after all these years. The game Cookie Clicker epitomized a design ethos that has since permeated a wide variety of game types and styles. The warm, gooey center of Cookie Clicker is what first hooked me all those years ago, and it’s still what keeps players coming back. In the right places, you can find examples of how that power has been used for both great good and terrible evil.

